Lean vs. Agile: The Grudge Match 2!
We had Lean vs. Six Sigma...Now it's Agile's turn
If you’ve spent any time in the world of project management, process improvement, or software development, you’ve likely heard of Lean and Agile methodologies. Both are hailed as game-changers, but they often get mixed up, misapplied, or seen as rivals.
Is Lean just another form of Agile? Does Agile eliminate waste like Lean? Should you choose one over the other, or can they work together?
We’ll break it all down in simple, no-nonsense language—so whether you’re new to these concepts or looking to refine your understanding, you’ll get clear, actionable insights on how these two powerhouse methodologies compare and complement each other.
What Is Agile?
Understanding Agile Methodology
Agile is all about flexibility, adaptability, and responding to change. Originating from software development, it helps teams manage uncertainty and deliver working solutions faster. Instead of long, rigid planning cycles, Agile uses an iterative approach, meaning work is broken down into small, manageable chunks called sprints.
Agile Principles
Agile is based on four core values outlined in the Agile Manifesto:
- Individuals and interactions over processes and tools
- Working software over comprehensive documentation
- Customer collaboration over contract negotiation
- Responding to change over following a plan
At its core, Agile focuses on
delivering value to users quickly while being open to continuous improvement.
What Is Lean?
Understanding Lean Methodology
Lean is a process-improvement methodology focused on eliminating waste, improving flow, and maximising value. It was pioneered by Toyota in the manufacturing industry but has since been applied to various business sectors, including healthcare, finance, and even software development.
Lean Principles
Lean follows five key principles:
- Define value from the customer’s perspective
- Map the value stream to identify and eliminate waste
- Create flow by optimising processes
- Establish pull by producing only what is needed
- Pursue perfection through continuous improvement
Lean is all about efficiency and effectiveness—removing anything that doesn’t directly contribute to customer value.
Lean vs. Agile: How Are They Different?
Key Differences Between Lean and Agile
While Agile and Lean share some similarities, they have distinct goals and approaches:
| Factor | Agile | Lean |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Delivering working solutions quickly | Eliminating waste & optimising flow |
| Approach | Iterative, short cycles (sprints) | Continuous, incremental improvements |
| Primary Goal | Adaptability & customer collaboration | Efficiency & value maximisation |
| Origins | Software development, project management | Manufacturing, service industries, business operations |
The Agile Mindset vs. The Lean Mindset
- Agile thrives in fast-changing environments where customer needs evolve.
- Lean works best in optimising structured processes where waste reduction is key.
- Agile welcomes change, while Lean focuses on efficiency.
Can Agile and Lean Work Together?
Better Together?
Absolutely! Many organisations successfully blend Agile and Lean principles to get the best of both worlds:
- Lean principles can help Agile teams streamline workflows and eliminate unnecessary steps.
- Agile principles can help Lean organisations become more flexible and responsive to change.
For example, companies like Toyota and Amazon integrate both Lean and Agile to improve efficiency while staying customer-focused.
FAQs About Agile
What is Agile methodology used for?
Agile is primarily used in software development but is also applied in project management, marketing, and business operations.
What are the benefits of Agile?
- Faster delivery of products/services
- Better collaboration
- Increased flexibility and adaptability
- Higher customer satisfaction
Is Agile only for software development?
No! Agile is used in industries like manufacturing, finance, and even HR to improve processes and workflow management.
Which is better, Lean or Agile?
Neither is "better"—it depends on the context. Use Agile when you need flexibility and rapid iterations. Use Lean when optimising processes and reducing waste is the priority.
Can Agile and Lean work together?
Yes! Many organisations combine Lean’s efficiency principles with Agile’s adaptability for maximum impact.
What companies are using Lean & Agile?
Companies like Amazon, Toyota, and Spotify use a combination of Lean and Agile principles to optimise operations and improve innovation.
So, is it Lean vs. Agile, or is it Lean & Agile? The answer is both! Whether you choose Agile, Lean, or a mix of both depends on your goals and challenges.
At VA Innovation, we help businesses implement process improvements, reduce waste, and drive efficiency. If you’re looking to optimise your operations or make Lean and Agile work for your team, get in touch with us today!
Top Lean Six Sigma Reads:
